Diving into D-STAR – 2
2) Choosing a way forward
Given all the interesting options that are available, how do you actually choose which combination of radio, hotspot, and software to use?
For me, this involved first doing lots of reading and watching lots of videos (see Links to helpful resources on the Notes page at the end of this article).
Then an Elmer tutored me. A shout out to the late Starr Aldrich, N0AES, of the Longmont Amateur Radio Club, who generously spent a good bit of time patiently answering my questions.
Next I came across some enthusiastic hams in southern Colorado, the Parker Radio Association, who are doing lots of fun digital radio-related work. Their site helped me gain a broader perspective about digital radio.
Finding all of these resources was a bit like being tossed a life saver … I was still in the soup, but at least my head was finally above water!
As one of my Elmers, George, KA0BSA, says, "When people ask me what ham radio is, I say it is a learning curve."
2a) Answering three key questions
One of the main things I've learned is that choosing a correct way forward comes down to answering a few key questions, the most important of which is:
1) Which systems do the people you want to talk with use?
Because the various digital voice systems can be largely incompatible, in many cases you'll want to be using the same system as the people you want to talk to. Knowing which base system you want to focus on can help you eliminate hotspots that don't support that system.
Beyond that, as much as is possible I'd also like the flexibility to explore other systems, so the next key question is:
2) How close to the cutting edge can you travel comfortably?
On one end of the spectrum is today's world of personal technology, which pretty much spoils us. The most complicated thing we need to do is figure out which OS we want to buy into. Then we simply download and install some apps and at most tweak a few easy settings. After that, it all pretty much just works.
On the other end of the spectrum are the SuperNERD geniuses designing and soldering their own boards, writing their own apps, and putting up repeaters.
Alas, I'm not a SuperNERD. While I'm willing to do some exploring closer to the cutting edge, I also know I should avoid solutions whose descriptions include terms like "experimental" or that require SuperNERD powers.
For example, the description of an early iteration of a multi-mode modem board in one of the PRA presentations says: "Requires deep experience in compiling and configuring software, and interfacing with hardware." Nope, not for me.
There's one final question I think is worth considering:
3) Is the technology open?
For what it's worth, I prefer open technology. When technology is open, more people can review it and contribute to its improvement and security. People also can use open technology more easily to experiment and innovate.
This means I prefer DV radios and reflector systems that are open to those that are proprietary and closed. I also prefer a hotspot that enables me to connect to multiple different reflectors over one that limits me to a proprietary system.
The openness factor is one I always carefully weigh when making decisions about the technology in which to invest my time and money. I still use proprietary solutions, but all other factors being relatively equal, I prefer an open one.
How would the Trojans have reacted if the Horse statue the Greeks gave them was made of glass and they could see right through it? They would have seen the malicious implants and removed them before letting the statue into their enterprise. That is my key thought about open-source software. Everyone can examine the code and look for and remove vulnerabilities….
Bob Gourley, Cognitio co-founder, former Defense Intelligence Agency CTO
2b) Before doing anything else
There are a couple registration processes that can take a few days to complete, so it's a good idea to get them started as soon as you can.
i) Register with the D-STAR Gateway System
To fully use the gateways on many D-STAR repeaters, you need to register with the D-STAR Gateway System, a system that shares callsign routing and other information across all the D-STAR repeaters within the system. It's easy enough to register, so it's worth doing this right away.
- Read the D-STAR Self Registration Instructions.
- Find the D-STAR repeater nearest to you that processes registrations. See the D-STAR Info website's repeater list. Note: If you don't have a local gateway system to register with, you can use D-STAR Gateway System (REGIST).
- It's important to register only once and with only one D-STAR Gateway. Your registration will be shared across the system. Once more: THIS IS IMPORTANT! If you register with two gateways, it can really mess things up for you when you start trying to use D-STAR.
- When you register, you can add up to eight radios, each distinguished by an initial that follows your callsign, so that when you transmit, the radio you're using can be identified.
- The first radio you register must be your callsign followed by an "initial" that is a blank space: use your spacebar to insert a blank space.
- It's totally optional whether you register any other radios beyond the first one; in fact, some people think adding multiple radios confuses things and can cause problems, so they recommend against it.
- The RPT option is used ONLY for registering repeaters. You can use your own callsign to run a hotspot, which are NOT considered repeaters.
- Once your registration has been processed, double-check that you registered everything correctly: DStar-Gateway Registration Check.
ii) Optionally, register with CCS7 for DCS (and DMR)
If you're going to be using the DCS reflector system (or DMR), you also need to register with an authentication and routing system called CCS7 (Callsign Communication System, 7-digit).
The DCS system uses the CCS7 ID number instead of your callsign, though its authentication service maps your CCS7 ID number to your callsign. The CCS7 system is now the authentication system for multiple systems.
Registrations for everywhere—including North America, South America, Asia, and Oceania, Europe, and Africa—are now all handled by RadioID.net.
The registration systems are administered by volunteers so be patient, it can take a few days to receive your CCS7 ID.
2c) Choosing a D-STAR-capable radio
Because of my good experience with the Kenwood TM-V71A mobile radio, when I started getting curious about exploring D-STAR and then saw that Kenwood had released a new D-STAR-capable HT, the TH-D74A, I was intrigued.
I suspected the TH-D74A might be a good choice for me, especially when I saw that the feature set also includes APRS with built-in GPS. Also nice: tri-band, bluetooth and USB connectivity, and IP54/55 weatherproofing. And it has a color screen, which isn't really necessary, but sure is sweet.
Once I got my hands on this radio, I quickly grew to like it. I find the way the interface is organized, especially the menu system, really easy to use.
I did swap out the stock rubber duck for a Comet HT-224. However, one thing I didn't like about the new antenna was that, because it is thinner than the stock one, it left a gap between the radio's antenna seat (5/8″ ID) and the HT-224 (3/8″ OD). I solved that by getting a $0.26 rubber gasket (3/8″ ID × 5/8″ OD × 1/16″ groove) at our local hardware store.
I sliced off one side of the gasket with a razor blade, and it makes a perfect seal: it fits snugly around the antenna, and also fits down in the antenna seat opening nice and tightly. Sometimes, you just get lucky! I think the gasket will help preserve the radio's IP54/55 weatherproofing, and it looks better, too, making the antenna look like a more natural part of the radio.
I think this radio is going to give me years of opportunities to explore and enjoy many areas of analog and digital communication.
2d) Choosing a hotspot
I then needed to decide which hotspot to use. That's when all the great information from Elmer Starr as well as some of the online info I came across really helped. One thing Starr recommended was to try a solution based on the little Raspberry Pi (RPi) computer, as there are several hotspot boards and USB sticks that work with it. That struck me as a good direction to head since I had never played around with an RPi and have wanted an excuse to try one out.
As Thorin Klosowski writes in his Lifehacker.com article, What I’ve Learned From Tinkering With the Raspberry Pi for Five Years:
[T]he Raspberry Pi is far, far away from being as user friendly as a PC or Mac. That’s a feature, not a bug. The Raspberry Pi is built to force you to learn troubleshooting, and that’s still one of my favorite things about it.
So I got an RPi 3B, and started tinkering with it. By default, it runs Raspbian OS (Raspbian is a version of Debian Linux that was created for the Raspberry Pi). I'm quite impressed with what this little credit card-sized computer can do. It even includes my favorite office suite, LibreOffice. Nice!
Then I turned my attention to the hotspot itself. There are many combinations of hotspot devices and software being developed by innovative hams, many of which support multiple digital voice systems including D-STAR, DMR, YSF, P25, NXDN, POGSAG, and multiple cross modes.
This is such a big topic that I've spun off an entire article describing how hotspots work and discussing the many available choices: Hanging out with hotspots.
Have fun choosing!